OMAHA — The first debate of the Omaha mayor’s race spent Tuesday amplifying what increasingly looks like a four-way fight to join three-term Mayor Jean Stothert in the May 13 general election.

Stothert’s top challengers in the nonpartisan April 1 primary — Democratic Douglas County Treasurer John Ewing, Republican former State Sen. Mike McDonnell and Democratic nonprofit executive Jasmine Harris — largely targeted the mayor and her record.

Also participating in the noon debate organized by WOWT and the League of Women Voters at the Omaha Press Club was community advocate Terry Brewer, who joined the race late.

Ewing, a former candidate for the U.S. House, and McDonnell, a former fire chief and fire union leader, criticized Stothert for focusing too much city time and money on the whims of some private developers.

Ewing said he wants the city to do a better job strategically planning development instead of being led around by the mayor’s favored developers, state incentives and the “hodgepodge” that results.

He told the Examiner that Omaha lags other Midwestern cities in growth because the city isn’t doing enough outreach and recruitment of current and future employers seeking long-term ties.

“I absolutely love being a public servant,” Ewing said. “It’s what I’ve done all my adult life. I believe it’s critically important that leaders keep their word.”

Streetcar Fight

McDonnell repeated his criticisms of Stothert for wasting money on an outdated streetcar she promised she would let the people of Omaha vote on and didn’t. He said the unpopular project should face voters.

During testy exchanges on public safety and services for the homeless, McDonnell sarcastically said Stothert has “a lot of great ideas” and questioned why she hasn’t implemented them in 12 years.

He mocked Stothert for taking credit for lowering the tax levy in Omaha, saying that reducing the increase in property taxes people pay is not a cut. He said she opposed state efforts to reduce property taxes.

“We have to control spending,” McDonnell said. “The first day in office … we’re going to zero out the budget and do performance-based budgeting. There’s something going on here.”

Harris, a former mayoral candidate who works with people returning to society from prison, jabbed at both Republicans for their handling of affordable housing and Omaha’s homeless.

She said Omaha needs a better focus on connecting people without housing to the kinds of services that help them adjust to living in new surroundings with new responsibilities.

Harris said much of the root causes of the city’s problems with public safety and homelessness are based on the lack of affordable housing being built, which the city could change.

She said people need more than just policing to feel safer, including a greater city focus on mental health care and substance abuse treatment.

“I’m not running for mayor to make it a career move,” Harris said. “I wake up every day to figure out how I can make life better for the people of Omaha. People want a change.”

Ewing, Harris and Stothert criticized McDonnell for pushing a proposed state law that they said would have criminalized homelessness as ineffective and costly. McDonnell, who pushed a proposal to help police address homeless encampments, criticized Stothert for letting homelessness increase.

Tuesday’s debate followed a mayoral campaign forum last weekend in North Omaha.

Stothert’s Defense

Stothert pointed to Omaha’s growth during her three terms. She said it’s too late to stop the streetcar project without getting the city sued. She said people care most about safety, taxes and roads.

Ewing and Harris agreed with Stothert that it was likely too late “to stop the streetcar now.” Both said Omaha needs a mayor that makes sure the city’s transportation system works for residents.

Stothert touted crime stats that show Omaha becoming safer, including just 19 homicides in 2024. She acknowledged needing more progress on juvenile crime and officer recruitment.

On Tuesday, she announced efforts to recruit more police officer candidates year-round and an effort to make sure Omaha pays more for police officers than any city in Nebraska.

“I love my job and I hope it shows,” Stothert said. “We’ve had 12 years of determination, of progress and of success. … Omaha is moving forward in every way.”

McDonnell, after the debate, said he was pleased that Stothert was listening to him and the constituents that had come to him with criticisms of how she was not hiring enough police officers.

His political team acknowledged that McDonnell faces attacks from all sides as a new Republican running against a GOP incumbent for mayor. Stothert had Gov. Jim Pillen as a guest at her table.

“I know one thing the four of us have in common is we think there should be a new mayor,” McDonnell said of his experience in the first debate.

Reaction From First Debate

Stothert, after the debate, said it was gratifying to hear candidates agree with her rather than McDonnell that it is too late to stop the streetcar without putting the city in financial jeopardy because of signed contracts.

She also said it was too late for a public vote on the streetcar, and that the only group that could call for such a vote is the Omaha City Council, which has already approved the project.

Asked about being the target of other candidates Tuesday, Stothert, seeking a fourth term, said it was old hat. She said she “expects it.”

“They’ll come and say you’re doing everything wrong and they’re going to do everything right,” Stothert said. “But … we’ve got an excellent story to tell about the progress we’ve made over the last 12 years.”

Brewer spoke often about the need to help young people engage with education and job opportunities. He said Omaha needs to offer young people more options than the streets, sports or college.

“Discipline is the key for success for us,” Brewer said. “I want to bring back programs that once helped me. I’m looking for the future of my babies … having a legacy.”

This story was published by Nebraska Examiner, an editorially independent newsroom providing a hard-hitting, daily flow of news. Read the original article: https://nebraskaexaminer.com/2025/03/11/first-omaha-mayors-debate-shows-...